Saturday, July 16, 2011

EQUAVIA: 1:400 Model comparison Lufthansa Herpa VS Dragon Wings

OBJECTIVE
 -This is your chance to vote for likes and dislikes of the manufacturer's effort to detail. I am just gonna hand you some closeups along with some real life images courtesy of www.airliners.net after 15 days of voting the superlative to detail will be announced.  Right under the images I may add a few specks which can not be recognized from the image like rotating wheels etc.

-Both are aircrafts B747-400's of German airline "Lufthansa". Since it is a quite popular airline I figures it would be of interest.

          Exhibit A                                                     Exhibit B 
Manufacturer : Herpa                                      Manufacturer : Dragon Wings
Product Code: 560139                                    Product Code: 55156 and 55483 special X-mas version
Release Year  : 2003-2008                              Release Year  : 2000-2002
Units made     : Limited                                    Units made     : Limited
Scale             : 1:400                                       Scale             : 1:400
Registration   : D-ABVW                                Registration   : D-ABVF

LEFT: Herpa / RIGHT: Dragon Wings  

LEFT: Dragon Wings  / RIGHT: Herpa  

Herpa Wings

Dragon Wings

Herpa Wings
 
Dragon Wings


GENERAL DETAILS
Herpa has a textured detail on the engine coils wings while Dragon is plain. There are more details on the cargo doors of  Herpa, while Dragon tilting wing gears. Dragon's windows are finer outlined where herpa used a plain grey. Herpa's type font for the Lufthansa Lettering is more bold and looks closer to reality, yet Dragon managed to get the blue color better. Herpa again made a better tone of Lufthansa yellow. Same goes for the grey of the Star Alliance logo, where dragon made that too dark.
The cockpit windows of Dragon look better, while Herpa has added more detail, like the top strobe lights etc

Take your close look and cast your votes in one of the three major Model Aircraft forums:
Click on your favorite forum to take you directly in the voting and discussion thread!



May the best wing.... win!

No comments:

Post a Comment